Monday, June 9, 2008

Water from another time

Water from another time…


What is the story that you tell yourself about your own life? What is your narrative? Does your story create your Self or does your Self create your story?

Kurt Lewin said that each time we act (think, speak, move, etc.), we are creating that act in that moment. He calls this contemporaneous causation. There can be no decisions for all time. According to Lewin, you are not an out-going person; you are a person who has chosen to be out-going at numerous instances in the past. Your future choices are yet undecided. Our choices are determined by all of the factors that surround and infuse us – historical/political situation, friendship groups, work place, financial considerations, physical surroundings, sexual desires, hungers, etc. He calls all of these factors together the “LifeSpace”. One of the most powerful factors in our LifeSpace is our past choices and how we frame them. Because if we frame our life up until now as good, positive, successful, promoting growth – well, then, our past choices must have been good as well. So, to make a new choice negates our self-concept. So, we make the same choice that we always make (not even considering it as a choice). The good news is you can make new choices; the bad news is the effort required can be enormous.


Old water pumps needed to be primed to operate. Without some water left over from the previous pumping, the pump will not work. Our lives require some water from another time as well. We use our stories of the past to validate our present and to aid us in making new choices. We tell the stories that match who we want to become and forget the ones that don’t. A friend has described many of my stories as having this theme, “There is some situation where some people didn’t think Steve belonged, but Steve shows them that he has a right to be in that situation more than most” - basically, a tale of rejection to acceptance. What am I telling myself? Where do I want to be accepted? Why is this the water I bring from another time to recreate myself here and now? A statement from another friend that I was ‘quite the social butterfly.’ And, I guess between dates and parties and , I can see what she meant. But, from my perspective I spend much more time alone that I have in the past. (Not lonely, but alone.)

In Israel I met a Holocaust survivor, the only Jew from her small village to survive the war. The mutual friend that introduced us told me, “She carries the people from that village with her wherever she goes.” How could she ever be lonely? Some days, I feel my own village embracing me. Grandparents, uncles, aunts, parents, friends, brothers/lovers - so many are gone, but always with me. They are my water from another time.

Thursday, June 5, 2008

A bird in the house is a death in the family.

There were no birds in the house I grew up in. By this I don't just mean live birds, but also images of birds. No partridge in a pear tree; no landscapes with pheasants in the background; no wallpaper with ducks on a pond. As far as I know it originated with my grandmother. Grammy would say, "A bird in the house is a death in the family." Once my parents ordered a sofa. The swatch of upholstery fabric they saw in the story didn't have a bird on it, but, when the sofa was delivered, there was a bird on the edge of the pattern. My parents sent the sofa back. My family was serious about their superstitions.

My parents bought the house I grew up in when my father got back from the war. The front porch wrapped around the side of the house. Every spring my dad would put up floor to ceiling screens that created a screened in porch. Every fall he would take them down. As soon as I was old enough to help, it was one of my favorite chores to help him with. Once the screens were up, there were three doors between the street and the house – the screen door we had just put up, the normal screen door, and the front door.

In the 44 years my parents lived in that house, a real bird made it through those three doors only once.

As usual we got the screens up from the cellar the first Saturday after my birthday. This ritual was a harbinger of spring. I had moved into my first post-college apartment in January, but still came home to help out with the bigger chores. I had no way of knowing it would be the last time I would help put those big screens up. Two weeks after we put the screens up, my father had a massive, fatal heart attack.

It rained the entire week leading up to my father's funeral, but the day of the funeral the sun finally came out. As was our custom, all the extended family and good friends came back to the house after the cemetery. As one of the last guests was arriving, a bird flew into the house. My sisters, my mother, and I went into a panic. After all those years, Grammy (by then more than a decade gone) was right, "A bird in the house is a death in the family."

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Beauty

Why are we attracted to someone else? Physical, personality, power, humor, accidents of location, shared interests, chemistry - these all may play a role. Today, I am thinking about physical attraction. Physical attraction is tricky. We can say someone is attractive and mean that they meet the dominant standard for beauty in our (sub)culture. Or, we can say someone is attractive and mean that we are attracted to them. And, often these two things are not the same. For some people they are even mutually exclusive. Being a fat gay man, I experience this very personally. Within gay male culture, slim or muscular are the body types that are considered attractive. (Just look at the ads in any magazine marketed to gay men.) So, the men who find me attractive are deviating from the standard of beauty for their culture.


When I first came out, I was not aware of the fact that there were any men who would find my body attractive. I mostly had sex with friends – men who were attracted to my non-physical aspects (my personality, my sense of humor, etc.) and who enjoyed the activities we were doing together. (Basically, when you are a 17, 18, or 19 male, sex is good, no matter where you find it.) As I got a little older, I realized that while I did not meet the standard for attractiveness in gay culture, there was a subset of gay men (chasers) who were attracted to my body. My early 20s were filled with these men. At first, I had a hard time accepting my own attractiveness in the eyes of chasers, and my lack of attractiveness within gay male culture at large. I had a very unhealthy coping mechanism when I first came to this awareness. I only dated chasers who were very attractive (meaning they met and usually exceeded the standard of beauty within gay male culture.) Some of these men had nicknames among my friends like ‘the model’ (who actually was a model) or ‘the most beautiful black man in Boston’ (a title he was given before I started dating him) or ‘the movie star’ (who was not a movie star, but did look like one). This would not have been so bad, except I also rejected chasers who I personally found attractive, but who did not meet the dominant gay male standard of beauty. I was not following my own measure; I was being pushed by the pressure of my subculture’s norms. I used these men I dated to validate myself - my own attractiveness. Eventually, I grew out of this phase.


The two long-term relationships of my adult life were with men I found very attractive. One of them was very attractive from a gay standard of beauty and one did not necessarily fit that standard. In my 40s, I am examining this issue of physical attraction again. From a 40-something place, it seems much more about person-specific issues than any sort of type – the texture of the skin, the shape of the nose, etc. – these things seem to be more important than the body as a whole. And, energy – that indefinable aspect of physical chemistry - seems to trump everything. I recently went on a date with a man, who was very close to my imagined physical ideal. Unfortunately, when we actually met, I felt no attraction. I could admire his body from an aesthetic perspective, but, after talking with him for just a few minutes, the energy just wasn’t there. That chemistry seems to be the essential component, I guess I just have to learn not to expect that energy with any particular type of man - and celebrate it where I find it.

Tuesday, June 3, 2008

The Coming Out Phenomenon…

"We have made great strides in defeating homophobia in the last 30 years. The single biggest reason, obviously, is that people have come out. -- Barney Frank (2004)

Coming out is a constant, moment-to-moment choice for folks who are not hetero-normative. We can be honest about our lives, or we can lie by omission or commission. The reason it is not a choice for hetero-normative folks is because they do not censor themselves on the basis of their gender, gender identity, sexual arrangements, affectional connections, or object of desire.

Examples: 1) A heterosexual teenage boy experiences his attraction to females as normal and supported by his community. He never has to limit his expression of his attractions because the object of his desire is female. (He may limit these expressions for other reasons, but not because the object is female.) A gay male teen would be coming out if he were equally honest about his attractions.

2) A middle-aged heterosexual female when talking about who she dated before she married her husband would not filter out any of these men because they were male. A bisexual female when talking about who she dated before she married her husband would be coming out if she listed both the men and the women she had dated.

3) A hetero-normative person is asked what they did last night. They have would not filter the fact that they went on a date with someone of the opposite sex. If I am asked the same question, I am coming out when I answer honestly about my date with another man.

4) A bio-man is asked about his childhood. He would not filter the fact that he was labeled a boy as a child. A trans-man would be coming out if he answered honestly about his childhood when he was labeled a girl.

In the last few years, I have had the chance to get to know some young LGBT folks who say, "My sexuality and gender idenity are my private business. I dont see any reason to come out to my friends (or co-workers, or siblings, or grandparents, or co-workers, or classmates, or parents, or roommates, or anybody)." This attitude is very hard for me to get my mind around. I understand being in the closet i.e., lying about your sexualityor gender history. And, there are many instances I support lying. Examples: 1) If your fundamentalist Christian parents are paying for your college education, I completely support lying to them about your sexuality until the final bill is paid, and the diploma is in your hand. 2) If, on a dark night, you are approached by a street gang, I completely support lying to them about your sexuality or gender history.

However, it seems that the people who say, "my sexuality is my business," don't see what they are doing as lying. They are systematically shutting some people out of an important part of their lives. They are engaging in non-reciprocal relationships, because it is an extremely rare hetero-normative person who does not reveal their sexuality to you within the first 30 minutes of meeting them. (Think about how many statements begin, "My husband and I" or "My wife and I".)

I think about my week. The people I see. The activities I do. How could I talk about my life without mentioning my sexuality? I would have to censor so many activities. How would I explain my connections to the boys I had fooled around with who I saw in a week? How would I describe the time spent with the men I am dating? How would I describe my discussions with the groups of LGBT folks I spend time in? How would I describe making breakfast in bed for two? It seems impossible to me to have a real relationship with anyone without being honest about my sexuality. I come out so many times a day that it is often a surprise to me when someone doesn't already know I am gay. But, believe it or not, I still have people who assume I am heterosexual.

My worry is about the progress that LGBT folks have made over the last 30 years. We have made this progress as Congressman Barney Frank says because LGBT people have come out. If the next generation takes a stance of "my sexuality is my business," I worry that some of this progress may be lost.

Harvey Milk said it best, "Come out, come out, where ever you are!"

Monday, June 2, 2008

The psychological contract

Perhaps the most essential (or master) problem in human relations is the assumption that other people's actions or inactions have the same underlying meanings as our own. I call this the master problem because we seldom deal with this problem in our relationships. Instead, we fight about the problems that are a consequence of this master problem. For example, we argue about cleaning, or the lack of a phone call, or an unwanted touch, but don't discuss the differences in meaning that these have for us.



We come to every human interaction with a set of expectations. Even when we are attempting to be free of expectations and go with the flow, we can not help bringing our expectations with us. Typically, we have different expectations for people in different roles in our life. The co-worker, the shop clerk, the friend, the lover, and the acquaintance each elicits in us a particular set of expectations based on our history, our culture, our upbringing, and our experiences. This, in and of itself, is not the problem. The problem is that we used these expectations (our psychological contract) to interpret the actions of others. So, when a 'friend' does something that does not match our 'friend contract', we no longer consider them a friend. Or, when a lover does not do the things our contract says a lover should do, we interpret this as a problem in the relationship as opposed to a problem in our psychological contract of what it means to be in a loving relationship.



One way to manage this problem is to only interact with people who have very similar psychological contracts to us. These are the friends who do all the things we expect a friend to do; the lovers who tell us what we want to hear. The problem with this approach is two-fold. First, it greatly limits whom you can successfully have interactions with. Secondly, when the places of difference are found (because no two people share exactly the same psychological contract) the betrayal can feel much deeper because there is no language to discuss the differences in expectations. However, this is a common strategy.



A more difficult path, though I believe much more fulfilling, is to work on noticing where you are giving meaning to actions (or the absence of actions) based on your own psychological contract. And, then, checking out your assumptions, before you act on them. The goal is to attempt to understand the other person – to learn their motivations before you begin to punish. At the same time, to begin to work on noticing how other people react to your actions, realizing that they are interpreting your actions through their own psychological contract.

Saturday, May 31, 2008

Backyard Plays

In my memory, they started when I was 5. Because they pre-dated the tutelage of Hood Elementary School. Though, it seems impossible that even I was precocious enough to be organizing and directing these extravaganzas at 5. I have only my memory to rely upon; my sisters were definitely out of the house by the time they began, and none others involved are available for me to ask. (I know my sisters were gone because the songs we performed were from their abandoned albums, or perhaps albums I stole from them as they prepared to leave. I was definitely precocious enough to have stolen my favorites from their collection as they packed up to leave.)


I do know that older kids - years older - were involved, though I was clearly in charge. (Some things seem to never change.) The skits were reenactments of scenes from my favorite TV shows or movies, or original creations written (well probably not written at 5) or created by me. My mother provided costumes as needed. The house my family had lived in for 25 years by then provided an assortment of props. My father's and grandfather's hats, my grandmother's walker, clothes from trunks in the attic, an assortment of accessories left behind by teenage sisters, visiting great-uncles and vaguely related English cousins filled the stage and adorned every type of character to perfection. Or, at least it seemed so to this pint-sized impresario.


In an early entrepreneurial venture (before I cut down the lilac bush and sold sprigs around the neighborhood from the back of my Radio Flyer Red Wagon), I charged parents (other peoples, not mine), older siblings, and various others connected somehow to my large cast five cents to see the show. It might not sound like much, but it bought an enormous amount of comic books in 1969. (It started the collection that I sold off to purchase my first computer almost 20 years later.) The shows were sprawling spectacles. Again, some things rarely change.


The shows were fully driven by me, but I often gave away most of the best parts to others. Though, I always saved a star turn or show stealer for myself. I remember jungle adventures, featuring my dog Andy playing any and all animals required. The adults seemed to especially enjoy some re-created movies scenes that held meanings hidden to the 7 and 8 year olds performing them, but clear to the parents. (And, definitely hidden from me, but I had an impressive memory for conversation even then, and could often repeat verbatim conversations of which I had no understanding. My mother had trained me to repeat back anything I overheard in neighbors' houses.)


I think all of my relatives were sure in my childhood that I would end up in some aspect of performance. And, maybe they were right. But, most of the performances have been in life, and not on a stage.

Friday, May 30, 2008

On being hated

"If no one hates you, you are not trying hard enough."


Perhaps there are people innocuous enough that, even when they are being completely themselves, they inspire no dislike, let alone hatred, in anyone else. But, I doubt it. My experience is that humans are so eccentric, diverse, unique, and crazy that when any one of us is completely ourselves, we will induce the full range of emotional reactions in others. Some will love us, some will hate us, and every other reaction in between.

What happens most of the time is that most of us hold back part of ourselves. We don't tell our whole truth. We don't take actions that those around us might judge. We filter ourselves. We pre-judge our actions by the standards of those around us. We don't say what we really want to say because of who is present in the room with us. We don't take risks, don't reach out, and don't call people on their shit.

When you meet someone who works outside those rules, someone who will not go along to get along, we tend to have a reaction. We love them or hate them. I am not perfectly free. I restrain myself in certain situations, but I probably express my true self more than most. As a result, I have my fans and my detractors. I have no problems with being hated. In fact, if I hear that someone really dislikes me, I figure I have managed to be truly myself with them. I feel the same way when someone I have only spent a little time with tells me or someone else that they really like me. Being hated is not a bad thing.

What sometimes confuses me is when someone I love being with is disliked by people who like me or vice versa. For example, I have a very theatrical friend who I love (and completely see myself in) who is disliked by a number of my other friends. I just can't see how my friends can like my "theatrical-ness", but dislike his. In another example, I am one of the most stubborn people I know, but I do have a friend who I think is perhaps even more stubborn than me. And, again it confuses me when our mutual acquaintances will feel one way about my stubbornness and the opposite about his, i.e., really like one of us and really dislike the other.

Though, there is perhaps a way in which I am perhaps particularly eccentric and that is that I don't mind at all being around people who hate me. If fact, I kind of enjoy it, because it is never clear whether they will decide to maintain the societal norms and be nice - or just break out the crazy. Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer - and frienemies are just their own thing all together.